Log in
Search
Latest topics
» Happy Birthday Robert ( Rsv1cox )by Levent Suberk Today at 12:49 pm
» The Cabin.........A carpenters nightmare.
by rsv1cox Today at 12:32 pm
» OS MAX-D
by Mike1484 Today at 10:07 am
» Cox .020 PeeWee/TeeDee prop-screw
by getback Today at 7:55 am
» Wanted peewee 20 fuel tank
by GallopingGhostler Today at 2:05 am
» Carburetor Sprinkler Rod Peak Tee Dee .049 / .051
by 1/2A Nut Today at 1:58 am
» Fox .35 Modifications
by Ken Cook Yesterday at 7:40 pm
» *Cox Engine of The Month* Submit your pictures! -October 2024-
by Admin Yesterday at 7:33 pm
» Off topic - Tonka dump truck restoration. 10:27
by rsv1cox Yesterday at 6:32 pm
» PSA propellors!!!
by robot797 Yesterday at 3:29 pm
» Internet buy
by rdw777 Yesterday at 11:38 am
» I Got Cheated!
by roddie Yesterday at 11:27 am
Cox Engine of The Month
Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
Page 1 of 6
Page 1 of 6 • 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
I have two of these kits, one complete with the additional radial mount (pictured) which will be put away
and one rather jumbled with missing parts and a cut up fuselage, but it came with a nice JW engine. I cut out a new replacement fuselage and a wing piece.
I have no idea why the PO cut up the original fuselage.
My Waterloo lately is finishing the completed model. Looking at Roberts nicely rendered "Simple Glider" with natural balsa and single red paint application revived an old idea I have had for some time. Just leave the model natural. Some sanding sealer followed by a couple coats of clear. I may do that.
But I do love color, especially the red, white, yellow on the box. Yellow especially, and look at the colorful Zipper that Kim is doing.
and one rather jumbled with missing parts and a cut up fuselage, but it came with a nice JW engine. I cut out a new replacement fuselage and a wing piece.
I have no idea why the PO cut up the original fuselage.
My Waterloo lately is finishing the completed model. Looking at Roberts nicely rendered "Simple Glider" with natural balsa and single red paint application revived an old idea I have had for some time. Just leave the model natural. Some sanding sealer followed by a couple coats of clear. I may do that.
But I do love color, especially the red, white, yellow on the box. Yellow especially, and look at the colorful Zipper that Kim is doing.
rsv1cox- Top Poster
-
Posts : 11069
Join date : 2014-08-18
Location : West Virginia
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
Looking forward to your Bonanza build Bob…. I think it, FireBee, and Firebaby are a significant part of pre Cox 1/2A history and worth exploring…. Thanks for the comment on the glider colors…. I tend to be in the less is more camp on small simple planes…A simple color or two on a neutral wood background causes the color to jump IMO…A lot of the old magazine articles suggested that approach…. I generally use tissue just because I can handle it better than paint…Lite and simple to repair too….. Not everyone’s choice though…. Decorating is a very subjective thing…. Kind of depends on the subject as well….
Bonanza could turn out very nice …. Fun to think of how you will finish something as it’s being built
Bonanza could turn out very nice …. Fun to think of how you will finish something as it’s being built
rdw777- Diamond Member
-
Posts : 1591
Join date : 2021-03-11
Location : West Texas
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
Robert, I have no idea how you can take those colored pieces of tissue and apply them so accurately and without tearing. Amazing. An airbrush could not do as well.
rsv1cox- Top Poster
-
Posts : 11069
Join date : 2014-08-18
Location : West Virginia
Doctor's Paper
rsv1cox wrote:Robert, I have no idea how you can take those colored pieces of tissue and apply them so accurately and without tearing. Amazing. An airbrush could not do as well.
Uh huh... yea.. what he said..
CEF member DanMc (Dan McEntee) sent me a sample of what he referred to as Doctor's Paper; a disposable paper that covers examination-tables and tears-off a roll..) which he was experimenting with. Not sure whether it is shrinkable for open-frame construction.. but I'm curious now; if it could be used (painted/tinted) to make trim like Robert has.
Its' thickness is .002" but I have not tried to use any yet
I had a doctor's appointment this past week.. and saw a box of rolls under the table and thought.... ....
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
Thanks Bob, Roddie ….. There was a time when raising a young family about all I could justify on modeling was rubber powered free flight….. Learned a lot about tissue work during that time ….. I still have a pretty good supply of Esaki tissue, it’s strong and holds its color well…. When I started flying gas again I just used what I had on hand….. Only regret is I’m running out of Sig Lite Coat dope which was my go to for working with tissue…. I ordered a few Sig Super Coat bottles while it was still available but I know it will shrink a lot more…. When I get ready to try it I’ll add some castor oil for retarder and test it on some thin balsa and maybe some open frames covered in tissue….. Thoughts from dope users?….Maybe it won’t be an issue if I stick with sheet surfaces…
I’ve read about people using that Doc paper Roddie…. I’ve taken a swatch or two from Dr visits…. Seems like it might be an OK substitute for light silk span…. If you decide to try it let us know how it works out….
I’ve read about people using that Doc paper Roddie…. I’ve taken a swatch or two from Dr visits…. Seems like it might be an OK substitute for light silk span…. If you decide to try it let us know how it works out….
rdw777- Diamond Member
-
Posts : 1591
Join date : 2021-03-11
Location : West Texas
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
Gentlemen,
Dan Mc turned me onto this stuff several years back. I began calling it DocSpan as the more common name is a mouthful! I've used it on my models since sometimes around 2018 or so. I discovered it has good shrink-rate, but with no real bias. I believe that lends to it swagging between ribs as it pulls front to back as well as side to side. It takes dope and clear sanding lacquer fabulously. My next plane will have stringers across the leading edge and the paper installed close to bone dry to minimize the swag. Look for my Brown-Novotnik Mosquito. You can see the swag in that deep rib set. The paper was damp. It shrank. It swagged. I doped again and hit it with a hair dryer, which promptly put the outboard "flap" in the raised position. I hope to "use the raised flap" to offset the line weight. Yeah...that sounds like a good reason for the "flip tip."
The typical stuff I find in medical offices near me is the shiny-on-both-sides more crinkly stuff. Beware if you grab a few feet from your doctor's office. What you want is "every day crepe exam table paper," sold by Tidi (or McKesson), part number 98-1002 (18" wide) or 98-1004 (21" wide). I think McKesson uses different leading digits, but the last four are the same. It is commonly found in 125 foot rolls, but 250 foot rolls may be available. The real clue is the "every day crepe."
I got mine several years back as a single roll for about $13 delivered. I have not found a single roll source since. A broken box appeared on eBay many moons ago for practically peanuts.
Dan Mc turned me onto this stuff several years back. I began calling it DocSpan as the more common name is a mouthful! I've used it on my models since sometimes around 2018 or so. I discovered it has good shrink-rate, but with no real bias. I believe that lends to it swagging between ribs as it pulls front to back as well as side to side. It takes dope and clear sanding lacquer fabulously. My next plane will have stringers across the leading edge and the paper installed close to bone dry to minimize the swag. Look for my Brown-Novotnik Mosquito. You can see the swag in that deep rib set. The paper was damp. It shrank. It swagged. I doped again and hit it with a hair dryer, which promptly put the outboard "flap" in the raised position. I hope to "use the raised flap" to offset the line weight. Yeah...that sounds like a good reason for the "flip tip."
The typical stuff I find in medical offices near me is the shiny-on-both-sides more crinkly stuff. Beware if you grab a few feet from your doctor's office. What you want is "every day crepe exam table paper," sold by Tidi (or McKesson), part number 98-1002 (18" wide) or 98-1004 (21" wide). I think McKesson uses different leading digits, but the last four are the same. It is commonly found in 125 foot rolls, but 250 foot rolls may be available. The real clue is the "every day crepe."
I got mine several years back as a single roll for about $13 delivered. I have not found a single roll source since. A broken box appeared on eBay many moons ago for practically peanuts.
_________________
Never enough time to build them all...always enough time to smash them all!
944_Jim- Diamond Member
-
Posts : 2018
Join date : 2017-02-08
Age : 59
Location : NE MS
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
The "Doc " paper was introduced on Stunt Hangar many years ago and I decided to try it on a 42" plane. My experience with it was not positive. I found it to not shrink like silkspan and even using Supercoat, it wasn't pulling out the wrinkles in the compound curves. It was removed and never used again. Polyspan works better aside from the fact it takes a fair amount of dope to obtain a good finish. Polyspan also doesn't have 1000 numbers attached to it. You order the Polyspan and you get what you ordered.
Polyspan will heat shrink prior to doping therefore the need to use a lot of taughtening dope is not required and is better for the longevity of the model. Especially for those using it on 1/2A's. I for one don't know why one would do that as I learned very early on that using silkspan covered models on 1/2A's is a total waste of time unless you want to repair the model everytime out. Using iron on covering is not heavier than a silkspan finish on a 1/2A.
As far as Lite Coat availability, I don't think were ever going to see Sig dope return. I was bs'd by Sig for 2 years telling me everytime I called that it would be in stock approx 2 weeks. Randolph offers non taughtening butyrate which is essentially Lite Coat. In addition, I don't like adding castor oil to dope. I know its what was done years back but it doesn't mix well and it can also cause fisheye issues not too mention lack of adhesion issues. Dave Brown Flex All is a terrific product which makes the final coats very supple and flexible. It can be hard to source but once you have it, a bottle will last forever. Adding it to Supercoat will essentially stop the shrinkage and plasticize it.
Polyspan will heat shrink prior to doping therefore the need to use a lot of taughtening dope is not required and is better for the longevity of the model. Especially for those using it on 1/2A's. I for one don't know why one would do that as I learned very early on that using silkspan covered models on 1/2A's is a total waste of time unless you want to repair the model everytime out. Using iron on covering is not heavier than a silkspan finish on a 1/2A.
As far as Lite Coat availability, I don't think were ever going to see Sig dope return. I was bs'd by Sig for 2 years telling me everytime I called that it would be in stock approx 2 weeks. Randolph offers non taughtening butyrate which is essentially Lite Coat. In addition, I don't like adding castor oil to dope. I know its what was done years back but it doesn't mix well and it can also cause fisheye issues not too mention lack of adhesion issues. Dave Brown Flex All is a terrific product which makes the final coats very supple and flexible. It can be hard to source but once you have it, a bottle will last forever. Adding it to Supercoat will essentially stop the shrinkage and plasticize it.
Ken Cook- Top Poster
- Posts : 5608
Join date : 2012-03-27
Location : pennsylvania
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
Thanks Ken for mentioning those products…. Will look into them and try and source!!… Perfect
rdw777- Diamond Member
-
Posts : 1591
Join date : 2021-03-11
Location : West Texas
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
The Doc paper would be fine on sheeting, open bays receives a big thumbs down from myself. The big problem I see with Sig products is that thinner is not available. This is essentially what makes Sig dope so good. The slower thinner offers a nicer shine, longer workability and no brush strokes when brushed. I was using Dupont 3608 S for years but it's not a substitute for the same workability Sig thinner offers. It was a fairly fast evaporative thinner but it was compatible with Brodak as well. The nice thing was I was purchasing the gallon for $24. The Dupont paint line is now Chromax and the 3608S is still available. It's no longer $24. Chromax offers 3602-S which I believe is similar to Sig.
The problem with these items is that purchasing them becomes difficult. The reality is they don't even want modelers spraying or brushing high voc paints and to obtain some of these products one needs to be in the business. My neighbor owns a body shop and even for him from his PPG paint line, the equivalent thinner I would require from PPG is $80 a gallon even at his cost. This is what makes buying direct from Randolph very easy. When I order from Randolph, it's essentially at my door the following day. Amazing service they have in regards to getting their product out the door.
The problem with these items is that purchasing them becomes difficult. The reality is they don't even want modelers spraying or brushing high voc paints and to obtain some of these products one needs to be in the business. My neighbor owns a body shop and even for him from his PPG paint line, the equivalent thinner I would require from PPG is $80 a gallon even at his cost. This is what makes buying direct from Randolph very easy. When I order from Randolph, it's essentially at my door the following day. Amazing service they have in regards to getting their product out the door.
Ken Cook- Top Poster
- Posts : 5608
Join date : 2012-03-27
Location : pennsylvania
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
I have a supply of old silkspan. Last time I used it was on my Sterling Nieuport 28 re-build a couple of years ago. I simply used Minwax sanding sealer both to glue it to the airframe and later to the silkspan itself. It does a great job shrinking the silkspan and fixing it to the balsa. Its water based.
The Bonanza is so much easier to build than scratching out the Firebaby Jr.. I only had to recreate a couple of pieces, the rest came from the partial kit.
The V tail is extreme, thankfully the plans give the correct position to glue. I'm sticking by wood glue as a substitute for epoxy. I would prefer using epoxy but it makes such a mess and I always mix way to much. I would think that most of us here do also. Probably enough epoxy wasted world wide each year to glue the Titantic back together and refloat her.
Wing is glued up and sanded. Not the prettiest balsa I have seen so perhaps instead of leaving it natural I will paint it like the box cover.
Elevators present a problem as they are two different sizes, I will have to check my complete box to see which is correct. I only have one control arm and it calls for two so I will have to build one. Seems they must be ganged together. But I have seen U/C planes where only one elevator was used.
The Bonanza is so much easier to build than scratching out the Firebaby Jr.. I only had to recreate a couple of pieces, the rest came from the partial kit.
The V tail is extreme, thankfully the plans give the correct position to glue. I'm sticking by wood glue as a substitute for epoxy. I would prefer using epoxy but it makes such a mess and I always mix way to much. I would think that most of us here do also. Probably enough epoxy wasted world wide each year to glue the Titantic back together and refloat her.
Wing is glued up and sanded. Not the prettiest balsa I have seen so perhaps instead of leaving it natural I will paint it like the box cover.
Elevators present a problem as they are two different sizes, I will have to check my complete box to see which is correct. I only have one control arm and it calls for two so I will have to build one. Seems they must be ganged together. But I have seen U/C planes where only one elevator was used.
rsv1cox- Top Poster
-
Posts : 11069
Join date : 2014-08-18
Location : West Virginia
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
Progress. V tail makes this thing, sets it apart. Used a jewelers triangle file to groove the lower part of the fuselage to accept it, angled the top.
I checked the complete Bononza kit to determine the correct split elevator. Mixed partial set had two different types. Made a new one out of 3/32" and shaped it like the factory did.
Wen Mac only controlled the inside elevator on their model.
Playing around with windshield/window options. I do not like the external wrap-around plastic windshield supplied. I don't care for the over lap. Thinking channeling the fuselage and snapping in stryene, securing with formula 560 which dries clear.
I checked the complete Bononza kit to determine the correct split elevator. Mixed partial set had two different types. Made a new one out of 3/32" and shaped it like the factory did.
Wen Mac only controlled the inside elevator on their model.
Playing around with windshield/window options. I do not like the external wrap-around plastic windshield supplied. I don't care for the over lap. Thinking channeling the fuselage and snapping in stryene, securing with formula 560 which dries clear.
rsv1cox- Top Poster
-
Posts : 11069
Join date : 2014-08-18
Location : West Virginia
rsv1cox- Top Poster
-
Posts : 11069
Join date : 2014-08-18
Location : West Virginia
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
Nice! If it were me..... I'd do the elevator/linkage the way that Wen Mac did it.
I have lots of old silk-span... really old.... Stuff that was in the Veco, Sterling, Goldberg and Top Flite kit-boxes that my Uncle gave me 30 years ago.. and they were probably 30 years old when he gave them to me. Many of those boxes had the unused silk-span, balsa and plywood scraps, glue-dotted plan-sheets, unused music-wire nose-gear, "Bear" sandpaper.. Celluloid sheets.. double-edge razor-blades.. empty dried-up glue-tubes.. memories. A couple of those boxes haven't been opened in 25+ years.
I have lots of old silk-span... really old.... Stuff that was in the Veco, Sterling, Goldberg and Top Flite kit-boxes that my Uncle gave me 30 years ago.. and they were probably 30 years old when he gave them to me. Many of those boxes had the unused silk-span, balsa and plywood scraps, glue-dotted plan-sheets, unused music-wire nose-gear, "Bear" sandpaper.. Celluloid sheets.. double-edge razor-blades.. empty dried-up glue-tubes.. memories. A couple of those boxes haven't been opened in 25+ years.
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
Nice! If it were me..... I'd do the elevator/linkage the way that Wen Mac did it.
I'm thinking about it. Its like a 60 degree angle on the V tail and unless you get both control horns aligned perfectly parallel with the fuselage and the correct off-angle on the V tail your going to have binding. But I will probably screw it up and do it anyway. That, and I'm going to have to build the control horns out of popsicle sticks.
My X son-in-law gifted me his Dad's stuff when he passed away, lot's of quality items in there but somehow I'm reluctant to use them. But they won't go to waste.
I'm thinking about it. Its like a 60 degree angle on the V tail and unless you get both control horns aligned perfectly parallel with the fuselage and the correct off-angle on the V tail your going to have binding. But I will probably screw it up and do it anyway. That, and I'm going to have to build the control horns out of popsicle sticks.
My X son-in-law gifted me his Dad's stuff when he passed away, lot's of quality items in there but somehow I'm reluctant to use them. But they won't go to waste.
rsv1cox- Top Poster
-
Posts : 11069
Join date : 2014-08-18
Location : West Virginia
rsv1cox- Top Poster
-
Posts : 11069
Join date : 2014-08-18
Location : West Virginia
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
Hi Bob, I scanned OZ Bonanza CL plans to see if there was a better trick to hooking up that V-tail (both elevators used)…. Looks like about the same as on your JW plan detail…. Kind of weird geometry for a single shaft passing thru two horns but should be OK with good alignment….
rdw777- Diamond Member
-
Posts : 1591
Join date : 2021-03-11
Location : West Texas
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
Just a thought on that V-tail elev. link... Rusty K. (God rest his soul) had a "Yak" control-line model that he used a "lucky box" (??) type design to connect the flaps.
Here's the THREAD..
Here's the THREAD..
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
Thanks roddie, I think of Rusty frequently. He left us good memories. Good stuff that you contributed, I have used that link design before.
But, I got to thinking about the V tail design and PM'd Robert about it............
Robert, I have been thinking about the V tail. Pitch, roll, yaw. No rudder to kick over. In a bank it's an airfoil/rudder, reduced yaw. Slide slipping must be fun. The built in V angle must be critical. Strange. It must be ok they sold a lot of them.
The aerodynamics of it must be analyzed somewhere on the net but I have not had the time to look for it.
Meanwhile I continue to fool around with it.
But, I got to thinking about the V tail design and PM'd Robert about it............
Robert, I have been thinking about the V tail. Pitch, roll, yaw. No rudder to kick over. In a bank it's an airfoil/rudder, reduced yaw. Slide slipping must be fun. The built in V angle must be critical. Strange. It must be ok they sold a lot of them.
The aerodynamics of it must be analyzed somewhere on the net but I have not had the time to look for it.
Meanwhile I continue to fool around with it.
rsv1cox- Top Poster
-
Posts : 11069
Join date : 2014-08-18
Location : West Virginia
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
Getting there, but I broke the top off the canopy drilling out the holes to mount the landing gear. Not a clean break either which will help in reattaching. CA ought to blend right in. Actually to my advantage, now I can cut a proper slot/groove for the windshield/window. Better access. Uprights defining the windows will have to be added after paint.
Stuff to be added. Belly pan, controls etc.. Its never over until its over.
Stuff to be added. Belly pan, controls etc.. Its never over until its over.
rsv1cox- Top Poster
-
Posts : 11069
Join date : 2014-08-18
Location : West Virginia
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
Last pieces of the puzzle.
Cemented the windshield/window in place and wicked some CA into the break. Stands out like a sore thumb but so what. Assemble, over-spray with clear add the controls and it's finished.
I like it. Might trace out another and paint it like the box picture. Pretty simple to do.
Cemented the windshield/window in place and wicked some CA into the break. Stands out like a sore thumb but so what. Assemble, over-spray with clear add the controls and it's finished.
I like it. Might trace out another and paint it like the box picture. Pretty simple to do.
rsv1cox- Top Poster
-
Posts : 11069
Join date : 2014-08-18
Location : West Virginia
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
I keep scratching my head regarding JW's V-tail elevator linkage.. and decided to search the web for ideas. A Stunthangar link came up, which has some interesting solutions/recommendations.
Stunthangar link
I like the "dual-pushrod" idea.. but not sure how that would work-out with a profile fuse. I suppose you'd need to "slot" the fuse for the outer-elevator's pushrod to pass through.
Stunthangar link
I like the "dual-pushrod" idea.. but not sure how that would work-out with a profile fuse. I suppose you'd need to "slot" the fuse for the outer-elevator's pushrod to pass through.
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
Walt Musciano on his Scientific Navy Cutlass: https://outerzone.co.uk/plan_details.asp?ID=3558 had only one elevon, the left one controlled by the bellcrank. The right one was fixed.
Outerzone plan thumbnail.
If your only intention is 'round & 'round without stunts, that could be a simplistic possibility.
Other option is to make flaperoos on the wing for control and fix the stabilizer.
Outerzone plan thumbnail.
If your only intention is 'round & 'round without stunts, that could be a simplistic possibility.
Other option is to make flaperoos on the wing for control and fix the stabilizer.
GallopingGhostler- Top Poster
-
Posts : 5611
Join date : 2013-07-13
Age : 70
Location : Clovis NM or NFL KC Chiefs
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
I like the "dual-pushrod" idea.. but not sure how that would work-out with a profile fuse. I suppose you'd need to "slot" the fuse for the outer-elevator's pushrod to pass through.
I will have to drill a hole roddie. Check JW's plan above upper right corner.
I would like to find that kit George.
I'm trying to honor as much of JW's concept as possible so I'm going to try to keep it as he designed it. My big departure is the windshield.
Glued the wing and belly pan on this afternoon.
I will have to drill a hole roddie. Check JW's plan above upper right corner.
I would like to find that kit George.
I'm trying to honor as much of JW's concept as possible so I'm going to try to keep it as he designed it. My big departure is the windshield.
Glued the wing and belly pan on this afternoon.
rsv1cox- Top Poster
-
Posts : 11069
Join date : 2014-08-18
Location : West Virginia
Re: Jim Walker Bonanza etc.
I am sorry but I think the fuse A Lodge looks funky/strange the way it put together for the engine mount , But other than that its coming right a long just me being me
getback- Top Poster
-
Posts : 10378
Join date : 2013-01-18
Age : 67
Location : julian , NC
Page 1 of 6 • 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
Similar topics
» Wen-Mac Beachcraft Bonanza
» Jim Walker
» Jim Walker Firebaby
» Jim won't run ??
» Jim Walker's birthday
» Jim Walker
» Jim Walker Firebaby
» Jim won't run ??
» Jim Walker's birthday
Page 1 of 6
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum