Log in
Search
Latest topics
» Tee Dee .020 combat modelby Ken Cook Today at 5:09 am
» Roger Harris revisited
by TD ABUSER Today at 2:30 am
» My latest doodle...
by batjac Yesterday at 10:05 pm
» Retail price mark-up.. how much is enough?
by gkamysz Yesterday at 9:29 pm
» Happy 77th birthday Andrew!
by roddie Yesterday at 9:22 pm
» My N-1R build log
by GallopingGhostler Yesterday at 3:04 pm
» Chocolate chip cookie dough.........
by roddie Yesterday at 1:13 pm
» Purchased the last of any bult engines from Ken Enya
by sosam117 Yesterday at 11:32 am
» Free Flight Radio Assist
by rdw777 Yesterday at 9:24 am
» Funny what you find when you go looking
by rsv1cox Wed Nov 20, 2024 3:21 pm
» Landing-gear tips
by 1975 control line guy Wed Nov 20, 2024 8:17 am
» Cox NaBOO - Just in time for Halloween
by rsv1cox Tue Nov 19, 2024 6:35 pm
Cox Engine of The Month
Scale nitpicking
Page 1 of 2
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Scale nitpicking
Would it be sacrilage to paint the stripes on the rudder of a mint late 60's PT-19 that came all yellow? The anal scale modeler in me is sick of looking at it.....just not right........too late!...base white coat is already applied . There are lines molded in the rudder for the proper 13 stripes.
OhBee- Platinum Member
- Posts : 698
Join date : 2016-03-23
Age : 73
Location : Minnesota
Re: Scale nitpicking
I think you'll have to remember that not all features were incorporated in the production models because of cost. If they can sell it successfully without all the cosmetic bells and whistles (appearance points) and undercut competition, then there is no need to add this additional detail.
Are you attempting for historical purity, or something for self satisfaction that still qualifies as a historical article?
Will it really matter 20 years from now?
Today I see antique cars painted with modern multipart and multicoat paints that are much more shiny than the original article, but people still appreciate them as historic pieces, and with modern solid state instead of the valve (tube) radios, modern aftermarket air-conditioning, and etc.
For most, their grandchildren will not appreciate the collectibles as much as their grandparents did. We see time and time again estate sales where the collectible engines and planes go for next to nothing, only to have an E-Bay seller make money off them. Their grandchildren have no real interest in them, except may be one or 2 items here or there.
So, it is up to you. You can't take it beyond the grave with you.
Plus remember, the older I get, the more cantankerous I get.
Are you attempting for historical purity, or something for self satisfaction that still qualifies as a historical article?
Will it really matter 20 years from now?
Today I see antique cars painted with modern multipart and multicoat paints that are much more shiny than the original article, but people still appreciate them as historic pieces, and with modern solid state instead of the valve (tube) radios, modern aftermarket air-conditioning, and etc.
For most, their grandchildren will not appreciate the collectibles as much as their grandparents did. We see time and time again estate sales where the collectible engines and planes go for next to nothing, only to have an E-Bay seller make money off them. Their grandchildren have no real interest in them, except may be one or 2 items here or there.
So, it is up to you. You can't take it beyond the grave with you.
Plus remember, the older I get, the more cantankerous I get.
GallopingGhostler- Top Poster
-
Posts : 5723
Join date : 2013-07-13
Age : 70
Location : Clovis NM or NFL KC Chiefs
Re: Scale nitpicking
If you want it that way...just DO it!! It is yours to enjoy as you want. I think the colored striped ones were a sticker that could be printed or purchased. If you do paint it, don’t worry, soaking in brake fluid will allow removal of the paint.
Marleysky- Top Poster
-
Posts : 3618
Join date : 2014-09-28
Age : 72
Location : Grand Rapids, MI
Re: Scale nitpicking
Ya...I see the later ones came with stickers for the rudder...but not the proper number of stripes! I just think it should look proper...awfull lot of unbroken yellow with my yellow fuselage. Something to do besides shovel snow. :It'll probably never get flown, but I have to look at it!
OhBee- Platinum Member
- Posts : 698
Join date : 2016-03-23
Age : 73
Location : Minnesota
Re: Scale nitpicking
Just do it. Unless you plan to sell it at a profit, who cares what it might do to the auction price on eBay. It's value will be greatly increased to the only one that matters.
Dave P.- Gold Member
- Posts : 477
Join date : 2017-07-31
Age : 67
Location : Durham, NC
Re: Scale nitpicking
Dave P. wrote:Just do it. Unless you plan to sell it at a profit, who cares what it might do to the auction price on eBay. It's value will be greatly increased to the only one that matters.
ABSOLUTELY!!!!!!!!!!!!
Uncle Wayne's Stuka wasn't very "collectible' back in 1968 when he customized it's rudder, but it sure is VERY special to his goofy nephew all these decades later!
It's your plane...make it what you want it to be!
Kim- Top Poster
-
Posts : 8625
Join date : 2011-09-06
Location : South East Missouri
Re: Scale nitpicking
A collectible is worth money only if you sell it. But then, I guess it's no longer a collectible.
I've been admonished several times, "If you do that, you'll ruin its value." OTOH, if it improves its value to me, who cares??
I've been admonished several times, "If you do that, you'll ruin its value." OTOH, if it improves its value to me, who cares??
Re: Scale nitpicking
What if it was left in its "pristine" collectible state and it winds up in an estate sale auction, along with all hobby items lumped together (engines, planes, radios, accessories, etc.) for a winning bid by an E-Bay seller at say $300 for the lot? Then they auction for winning bid for $300? (and mebbe it was someone here from CEF who got your item? ) They make say $1,000 off your items that don't benefit your beneficiaries.andrew wrote:I've been admonished several times, "If you do that, you'll ruin its value." OTOH, if it improves its value to me, who cares??
Who is the real real winner?
It didn't belong to an estate by Elvis, JFK, Michael, otro presidentes, etc., then which would add tremendous value, but by all means one of the "yours truly's" on CEF. Being para la gente del mundo (of the people of the world), in essence our items are of value to us more than others. We don't count much (in a worldly sense) when compared to the rich and famous.
Thus, anything we do with our pasatiempos (hobbies) is really to benefit us in our happiness, and the loved ones and friends in the present time we share them with.
GallopingGhostler- Top Poster
-
Posts : 5723
Join date : 2013-07-13
Age : 70
Location : Clovis NM or NFL KC Chiefs
Re: Scale nitpicking
GallopingGhostler wrote:................We don't count much (in a worldly sense) when compared to the rich and famous.
Thus, anything we do with our pasatiempos (hobbies) is really to benefit us in our happiness, and the loved ones and friends in the present time we share them with.
And therein lies the whole truth of the matter.
Re: Scale nitpicking
Ya...what the heck....it's not like I plan to sell it ,or it's worth a fortune to begin with! Just more crap to dispose of when I'm gone!.......paint job is becoming a bit more tricky to do than I expected though!
OhBee- Platinum Member
- Posts : 698
Join date : 2016-03-23
Age : 73
Location : Minnesota
Re: Scale nitpicking
I hope you are using fuel proof paint, especially since you indicated a hope to fly it.
944_Jim- Diamond Member
-
Posts : 2022
Join date : 2017-02-08
Age : 59
Location : NE MS
Re: Scale nitpicking
What paint is fuel proof?...I don't remember? I doubt my Krylon and testors enamels are. I could put something over it all.....which probably will also eat my paint job! Probably won't get flown anyway...though I did think the old girl should at least get in the air once more! I need something else simple and cheap to get back into C/l...I thought this was it,but am having second thoughts as it is just too nice to screw up trying to relearn.
OhBee- Platinum Member
- Posts : 698
Join date : 2016-03-23
Age : 73
Location : Minnesota
Re: Scale nitpicking
There are plans floating around for a corrugated plastic PT-19 clone. It appears to be a model that really uses very little glue and paint. The colorizing comes from whatever plastic was selected. It does require some screws, blocks of wood, and a donor engine like a Babe Bee. The bonus is it won't take a whole lot of "money-in" if you can scrounge the plastic from a sign-making company.
The blocks of wood only need to be sealed if the model is to survive beyond a summer.
I have read that Krylon and Rust-Oleum are fuel-proof if left to cure for a few weeks. Spray poly-urethane will cover your paints and provide fuel-proofing, once the paints have cured (not just dries to touch).
If you lived down south, I'd hand you a control handle and fuel/start your "new" adventure for you.
The blocks of wood only need to be sealed if the model is to survive beyond a summer.
I have read that Krylon and Rust-Oleum are fuel-proof if left to cure for a few weeks. Spray poly-urethane will cover your paints and provide fuel-proofing, once the paints have cured (not just dries to touch).
If you lived down south, I'd hand you a control handle and fuel/start your "new" adventure for you.
944_Jim- Diamond Member
-
Posts : 2022
Join date : 2017-02-08
Age : 59
Location : NE MS
Re: Scale nitpicking
Jim...I WISH I was down south right now! I've had it with the cold and snow shoveling. I do recall some planes made out of that corrogated plastic stuff. I even had some lined up last year,but that fell through...or my donors forgot and threw it away! Look kinda "ghetto" though! And how can they fly with a flat wing? I kinda like that little P-40 you built with the .049 on it. Something like that would be a good starter plane I think.
OhBee- Platinum Member
- Posts : 698
Join date : 2016-03-23
Age : 73
Location : Minnesota
Re: Scale nitpicking
How can they fly with that flat wing you ask. Just fine is the answer. Just don't expect it to fly as nice as a built up model, but they do fly nice and also can do loops for fun. Virtually indestructable as well, with teh only thing I have had to do is to bend the motor mount back to shape/in place.
Here is the PT-19 Coroplast variant taken when I just finished it.
And here is the Man-Win Trainer, designed by a club member locally.
Here is the PT-19 Coroplast variant taken when I just finished it.
And here is the Man-Win Trainer, designed by a club member locally.
NEW222- Top Poster
- Posts : 3896
Join date : 2011-08-13
Age : 46
Location : oakbank, mb
NEW222- Top Poster
- Posts : 3896
Join date : 2011-08-13
Age : 46
Location : oakbank, mb
Re: Scale nitpicking
Thanks New 222!..... novel idea
OhBee- Platinum Member
- Posts : 698
Join date : 2016-03-23
Age : 73
Location : Minnesota
Re: Scale nitpicking
Flat wing causes lift through angle of attack, deflecting air downward as it moves through the air. It works for our models because we aren't lifting a whole lot of weight requiring more efficient means of lift.OhBee wrote:And how can they fly with a flat wing?
All the Sterling Beginner series (and later Estes who bought Sterling) with solid balsa wings are flat plate wings made of 3/32" or 1/8" balsa. Other manufacturers followed suit to include Dumas, Scientific and Goldberg on their least expensive series, Midwest, etc.
Walt Musciano, designer for Scientific liked putting airfoils on most of his designs. For simplicity of building he used the standard modified Clark-Y airfoil with flat bottom. Wing lifts well at lower angle of attack but inverted requires greater angle of attack. Most of his designs were sport designs not for serious stunting. (But they taught many a child and young man how to build things, something that is a lost art these days.)
GallopingGhostler- Top Poster
-
Posts : 5723
Join date : 2013-07-13
Age : 70
Location : Clovis NM or NFL KC Chiefs
Re: Scale nitpicking
Makes sense ghost....I've noticed the cheapest kits are plain flat balsa wings. Not fond of the look, I couldn't possibly have totally lost the ability to fly controline.....I currently fly R C so I know how to control flight that way just fine. I suspect over controling is as detrimental to controline as it is to RC flying. I would think anything with a built up wing would be easier to control. Not real concerned with augering in immediatly!
OhBee- Platinum Member
- Posts : 698
Join date : 2016-03-23
Age : 73
Location : Minnesota
Re: Scale nitpicking
OhBee,
I would recommend the Brodak Baby Clown. The ARF version is what I used to return to the hobby after 49 years of no C/L flying.
What I like is that it looks good, flew good, and is not expensive.
Mine is sitting here years later undamaged, and in completely flyable condition. The controls were installed at the factory with the lead out's terminated in crimped on line connecters (that I was a little worried about), but they still work fine!
Brodak offers the Baby Clown in kit form, plus ARF, and ARC versions as well. I still have a new kit on the shelf, and another ARF or two that I had hoped to give to my great-grandsons, but that did not work out due to family separations.
Check out Pat Kings site. He is in the Vendors section of Stunthanger.com, and has plans and kits for a lot of fine models! Look for PDK LLC, and check him out.
Another fine flyer is the Baby Flite Streak that I've also flown. It really flew well, but was faster, and more fragile than the Clown, and didn't survive a figure nine I stupidly attempted.
My first flight was with a friends coroplast trainer combat wing. He insisted that I could not damage it, so I gave it a go. Much to my surprise I flew out the complete tank (praying for it to run out the entire time), and then landed successfully, but fell on my butt immediately after landing! I was so damn dizzy that the trees and clouds were still spinning around minutes later, as I laid there laughing my head off!
We should probably take this off line, as its completely off topic. We do have similar experiences to talk about, that would probably bore everyone else.
My email is: wgadair@comcast.net
Bill
I would recommend the Brodak Baby Clown. The ARF version is what I used to return to the hobby after 49 years of no C/L flying.
What I like is that it looks good, flew good, and is not expensive.
Mine is sitting here years later undamaged, and in completely flyable condition. The controls were installed at the factory with the lead out's terminated in crimped on line connecters (that I was a little worried about), but they still work fine!
Brodak offers the Baby Clown in kit form, plus ARF, and ARC versions as well. I still have a new kit on the shelf, and another ARF or two that I had hoped to give to my great-grandsons, but that did not work out due to family separations.
Check out Pat Kings site. He is in the Vendors section of Stunthanger.com, and has plans and kits for a lot of fine models! Look for PDK LLC, and check him out.
Another fine flyer is the Baby Flite Streak that I've also flown. It really flew well, but was faster, and more fragile than the Clown, and didn't survive a figure nine I stupidly attempted.
My first flight was with a friends coroplast trainer combat wing. He insisted that I could not damage it, so I gave it a go. Much to my surprise I flew out the complete tank (praying for it to run out the entire time), and then landed successfully, but fell on my butt immediately after landing! I was so damn dizzy that the trees and clouds were still spinning around minutes later, as I laid there laughing my head off!
We should probably take this off line, as its completely off topic. We do have similar experiences to talk about, that would probably bore everyone else.
My email is: wgadair@comcast.net
Bill
smooth_bill- Gold Member
- Posts : 229
Join date : 2012-02-19
Age : 87
Location : Beaverton, OR
OhBee- Platinum Member
- Posts : 698
Join date : 2016-03-23
Age : 73
Location : Minnesota
Re: Scale nitpicking
I Did it! I POSTED A PIC!! Yaaay!.....Now dosn't that look 100% better?....Thank you rsv1Cox for the simple picture posting procedure for idiots. I wrote it down and followed it and it worked! I just wasn't doing it in the right order.
OhBee- Platinum Member
- Posts : 698
Join date : 2016-03-23
Age : 73
Location : Minnesota
Re: Scale nitpicking
Mr. Steve (OhBee)...good for you posting a picture. The paintwork is awesome!
The suggestion of the Baby Clown is solid. The fat wing should slow the plane down a bit compared to other built up wings, yet float well on a dead engine. I keep looking for plans for a thick wing Baby Clown.
I seem to remember someone doing a Baby Super Clown (flapped) quite some time ago. It was a crash rebuild if I remember right. Mr. Ron, was it you? I'd love to get templates/patterns.
Mr. Bill,
Please continue here. Threads drift, and come back to topic often here. It is part of "the culture" that is "only/barely" tolerated on some sites.
But on CEF, we enjoy the drift as much as the point!
The suggestion of the Baby Clown is solid. The fat wing should slow the plane down a bit compared to other built up wings, yet float well on a dead engine. I keep looking for plans for a thick wing Baby Clown.
I seem to remember someone doing a Baby Super Clown (flapped) quite some time ago. It was a crash rebuild if I remember right. Mr. Ron, was it you? I'd love to get templates/patterns.
Mr. Bill,
Please continue here. Threads drift, and come back to topic often here. It is part of "the culture" that is "only/barely" tolerated on some sites.
But on CEF, we enjoy the drift as much as the point!
944_Jim- Diamond Member
-
Posts : 2022
Join date : 2017-02-08
Age : 59
Location : NE MS
Re: Scale nitpicking
Ya...Baby clown, lil jumping bean...that is the type I'm interested in at first. Would love to build another Lil Satan like I used to fly. Might be a bit quick for an old beginner now...lots of choices,hard to narrow it down...they all appear so similar. ....but I'm steering towards the largest wingspan an .049 can haul. I can see this getting out of hand in a hurry! A couple larger engines and the choices become even more bewildering!.....but do love the Cox .049's!
OhBee- Platinum Member
- Posts : 698
Join date : 2016-03-23
Age : 73
Location : Minnesota
Re: Scale nitpicking
Mr. Steve,
Have you got a buddy that will help you launch wheel-less models?
Otherwise you will need wheels and a stooge.
My last Lil Satan was scratch-built from plans on flyinglines.org. In fact, that one was covered with gift tissue (or new shoe tissue) and clear dope. Color changes could be done by using colored gift tissue. I used whatever I could get my hands on locally so it wouldn't be expensive. My boys' Scientific clones used 15 lb picture hanging wire for lead-outs.
I say knock one out with an extra bay on the inboard wing and convert it to something else with a profile fuselage. That gives you someplace to hang wheels from while offsetting the weight of landing gear with some back-end weight. Them mount one of your Babe Bees and enjoy a leisurely Roundie-Roundie before deciding to jump all-in on a .15. model.
Have you got a buddy that will help you launch wheel-less models?
Otherwise you will need wheels and a stooge.
My last Lil Satan was scratch-built from plans on flyinglines.org. In fact, that one was covered with gift tissue (or new shoe tissue) and clear dope. Color changes could be done by using colored gift tissue. I used whatever I could get my hands on locally so it wouldn't be expensive. My boys' Scientific clones used 15 lb picture hanging wire for lead-outs.
I say knock one out with an extra bay on the inboard wing and convert it to something else with a profile fuselage. That gives you someplace to hang wheels from while offsetting the weight of landing gear with some back-end weight. Them mount one of your Babe Bees and enjoy a leisurely Roundie-Roundie before deciding to jump all-in on a .15. model.
944_Jim- Diamond Member
-
Posts : 2022
Join date : 2017-02-08
Age : 59
Location : NE MS
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Similar topics
» Me 163 in 1/32 scale
» Hobby Shop run - most of a PT-19
» More Old Stuff...
» Printing out .pdf plans to scale
» 1/3 scale airplane
» Hobby Shop run - most of a PT-19
» More Old Stuff...
» Printing out .pdf plans to scale
» 1/3 scale airplane
Page 1 of 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum