Log in
Search
Latest topics
» Roger Harris revisitedby rsv1cox Today at 3:38 pm
» My N-1R build log
by GallopingGhostler Today at 3:04 pm
» Tee Dee .020 combat model
by 1/2A Nut Today at 2:43 pm
» Chocolate chip cookie dough.........
by roddie Today at 1:13 pm
» Purchased the last of any bult engines from Ken Enya
by sosam117 Today at 11:32 am
» Free Flight Radio Assist
by rdw777 Today at 9:24 am
» My latest doodle...
by batjac Yesterday at 9:47 pm
» Funny what you find when you go looking
by rsv1cox Wed Nov 20, 2024 3:21 pm
» Landing-gear tips
by 1975 control line guy Wed Nov 20, 2024 8:17 am
» Cox NaBOO - Just in time for Halloween
by rsv1cox Tue Nov 19, 2024 6:35 pm
» Canada Post strike - We are still shipping :)
by Cox International Tue Nov 19, 2024 12:01 pm
» Duende V model from RC Model magazine 1983.
by getback Tue Nov 19, 2024 6:08 am
Cox Engine of The Month
Cox .15 Medallion Vibration - fixing vibration
Page 1 of 1
Cox .15 Medallion Vibration - fixing vibration
I bench ran a Cox .15 Medallion last week and it had much vibration.
This leads me to a basic question - is the prop shaft balanced, in general, in engines?
And, then, has anyone balanced one of these shafts for the .15 Medallion?
Having a way to test balance is the first objective.
The second is then machining it in a lathe to achieve balance.
Cheers,
Peter
This leads me to a basic question - is the prop shaft balanced, in general, in engines?
And, then, has anyone balanced one of these shafts for the .15 Medallion?
Having a way to test balance is the first objective.
The second is then machining it in a lathe to achieve balance.
Cheers,
Peter
PeterJGregory- Gold Member
- Posts : 144
Join date : 2014-07-28
Age : 61
Location : Hudson Valley, New York
Re: Cox .15 Medallion Vibration - fixing vibration
Peter are you sure it us the shaft and not the prop which is unbalanced?
balogh- Top Poster
-
Posts : 4958
Join date : 2011-11-06
Age : 66
Location : Budapest Hungary
Re: Cox .15 Medallion Vibration - fixing vibration
Peter, I have seen this many times and it was a very common problem with the Medallion .15. Make certain the piston isn't coming above the glow plug landing. I bet it is by a tiny bit. The solution is to add another head gasket or use a Fox .35 head gasket and shim the cylinder higher. You can place a wire laying it on the plug landing with the plug removed and rotate the engine and see if it pushes the wire off of the landing. However, excessive ball socket play if it is a ball socket version and not a conrod is unrecognized here and that play in itself can cause the piston to just slightly strike the plug causing the problem your experiencing. Ken
Ken Cook- Top Poster
- Posts : 5637
Join date : 2012-03-27
Location : pennsylvania
Re: Cox .15 Medallion Vibration - fixing vibration
Ken has more experience with the various engines so listen to and re read what he said.
The basic question begs a bit more thought,,,,ALL single cylinder engines are going to have a lot-- or SOME imbalance ----just simply due to no real way to counter balance all the rotating parts ---for all RPMs ... again.... for ALL RPMs
Add in the dynamics of a propeller--- within the power stroke ----(given we have perfectly balanced the prop) ----and we actually can mathematically determine the rate of imbalances based on all the rotating mass
BUT who the hell, besides the engine testing guys, wants to do all that
I was taught, at an early age, to always clock the prop so that it was horizantal (against compression) when the engine quit
That way, landing (without LG and wheels ) would not have a prop blade digging in
And to this day I still clock all my combat prop engines for horizontal stop
Some may have noted I bench run ALL my engines...several reasons...NONE really about break in
ONE distinct reason is balance. Especially for Landing Gear planes.... in this case prop stop orientation is NOT critical but vibration of the total air-frame IS
I always start with the prop set to good horizontal stop against compression with engine quit
BUT---- IF on the bench, I have noticeable vibration, I do play with the prop clocking to reduce or eliminate the vibration
I have read--- but do not condone...more than one old guy who uses deliberately OUT of Balance Prop blades to Tame Fox .35 vibrations...NOT condone, because there is simply no way to repeat the condition
The basic question begs a bit more thought,,,,ALL single cylinder engines are going to have a lot-- or SOME imbalance ----just simply due to no real way to counter balance all the rotating parts ---for all RPMs ... again.... for ALL RPMs
Add in the dynamics of a propeller--- within the power stroke ----(given we have perfectly balanced the prop) ----and we actually can mathematically determine the rate of imbalances based on all the rotating mass
BUT who the hell, besides the engine testing guys, wants to do all that
I was taught, at an early age, to always clock the prop so that it was horizantal (against compression) when the engine quit
That way, landing (without LG and wheels ) would not have a prop blade digging in
And to this day I still clock all my combat prop engines for horizontal stop
Some may have noted I bench run ALL my engines...several reasons...NONE really about break in
ONE distinct reason is balance. Especially for Landing Gear planes.... in this case prop stop orientation is NOT critical but vibration of the total air-frame IS
I always start with the prop set to good horizontal stop against compression with engine quit
BUT---- IF on the bench, I have noticeable vibration, I do play with the prop clocking to reduce or eliminate the vibration
I have read--- but do not condone...more than one old guy who uses deliberately OUT of Balance Prop blades to Tame Fox .35 vibrations...NOT condone, because there is simply no way to repeat the condition
fredvon4- Top Poster
-
Posts : 4012
Join date : 2011-08-26
Age : 69
Location : Lampasas Texas
Re: Cox .15 Medallion Vibration - fixing vibration
Thanks for fast replies with some new info to me.
I did balance the prop so that is not part of the equation. But I can recheck.
The piston/head bump issue I can check when I get back to the engine next week.
I do not believe there is any piston-wristpin-connecting rod slop that I can detect by a wiggle test. I will have to check whether it is a wrist pin or socket version.
I've heard of the Fox offset-imbalanced-prop trick, and should have thought of doing a little partial rotation test with the prop now no it - that good tip is noted for the future and much appreciated.
I'll post progress when I get back to the engine - thanks...
I did balance the prop so that is not part of the equation. But I can recheck.
The piston/head bump issue I can check when I get back to the engine next week.
I do not believe there is any piston-wristpin-connecting rod slop that I can detect by a wiggle test. I will have to check whether it is a wrist pin or socket version.
I've heard of the Fox offset-imbalanced-prop trick, and should have thought of doing a little partial rotation test with the prop now no it - that good tip is noted for the future and much appreciated.
I'll post progress when I get back to the engine - thanks...
PeterJGregory- Gold Member
- Posts : 144
Join date : 2014-07-28
Age : 61
Location : Hudson Valley, New York
Re: Cox .15 Medallion Vibration - fixing vibration
PS - I just saw the Ringmaster-a-thon 2017 is planned for Sat & Sun 7 & 8 Oct and plan on getting this engine on a RM Jr.
I'll have at least 3-4 1/2A or 1/2APlus Baby RM's and RM Jr.'s for that - hope you are all flying, too.
I was just getting into the swing of things last year, and could not start my Tee Dee .09 RM Jr. before it got too dark - grrr.
Since then I have fashioned my LiPo-driven, full digital readout GCS Charger - Glow Charger Supreme Charger.
Because life is too short not too have good glow.
Here's a non-close up of the charger with a Mark's Models Wanderer I was flying this summer with a Tee Dee .051,
which has a black throttle body because that is what is available on eBay these days.
Edit - and I was able to post a closer up pic of the GCS...
Closer up
I'll have at least 3-4 1/2A or 1/2APlus Baby RM's and RM Jr.'s for that - hope you are all flying, too.
I was just getting into the swing of things last year, and could not start my Tee Dee .09 RM Jr. before it got too dark - grrr.
Since then I have fashioned my LiPo-driven, full digital readout GCS Charger - Glow Charger Supreme Charger.
Because life is too short not too have good glow.
Here's a non-close up of the charger with a Mark's Models Wanderer I was flying this summer with a Tee Dee .051,
which has a black throttle body because that is what is available on eBay these days.
Edit - and I was able to post a closer up pic of the GCS...
Closer up
PeterJGregory- Gold Member
- Posts : 144
Join date : 2014-07-28
Age : 61
Location : Hudson Valley, New York
Similar topics
» Cox Surestart 049 vibration
» PeeWee .020 bent cylinder
» Micro 12VDC Generator with a Cox .049 Sure Start Diesel Engine
» I think I have a problem...
» Medallion 049 & Medallion 049; what is the difference?
» PeeWee .020 bent cylinder
» Micro 12VDC Generator with a Cox .049 Sure Start Diesel Engine
» I think I have a problem...
» Medallion 049 & Medallion 049; what is the difference?
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum