Log in
Search
Latest topics
» Retail price mark-up.. how much is enough?by gkamysz Today at 9:29 pm
» Happy 77th birthday Andrew!
by roddie Today at 9:22 pm
» Roger Harris revisited
by rsv1cox Today at 3:38 pm
» My N-1R build log
by GallopingGhostler Today at 3:04 pm
» Tee Dee .020 combat model
by 1/2A Nut Today at 2:43 pm
» Chocolate chip cookie dough.........
by roddie Today at 1:13 pm
» Purchased the last of any bult engines from Ken Enya
by sosam117 Today at 11:32 am
» Free Flight Radio Assist
by rdw777 Today at 9:24 am
» My latest doodle...
by batjac Yesterday at 9:47 pm
» Funny what you find when you go looking
by rsv1cox Wed Nov 20, 2024 3:21 pm
» Landing-gear tips
by 1975 control line guy Wed Nov 20, 2024 8:17 am
» Cox NaBOO - Just in time for Halloween
by rsv1cox Tue Nov 19, 2024 6:35 pm
Cox Engine of The Month
dieselized Black Widow
Page 1 of 1
dieselized Black Widow
I recently acquired several diesel Cox .049's. I toyed with my version a few months back using the RJL head with fair results. The positives were easy starts. The negatives however outweigh the opposing. I found the engine to be gutless using a 7x4, it broke my crank not to mention. I replaced it using a Davis Diesel crank. I switched to the Davis Diesel head and found that to be the biggest pain in the rear I ever experienced. My engine was just a regular Babe Bee on a production backplate. Today, I took out some of the engines recently given to to me. The Black Widow looked very clean and nice and it had Davis Diesel head not to mention crank. I put a Cox grey 5x3 and it instantly came to life. The engine sounds as though it's making useable power for my control line use. I was rather shocked at the sound of it actually. No tach in my hand but I could certainly tell it was an exceptional improvement over the 7x4. The problem though was as it heated up, I had to keep backing off the compression and opening the needle to keep it from going over. I really don't know how to set this up on launch. Should I keep it running in a very low compressed state prior to launch? I know this thing will unload and go over if launched to where it sounds good. It changes it's tone about every 10 seconds as it heats up. Should I run a ground tank on it to get heat first and then go out for a flight? This engine is using the DD head and it was working rather well. I put the 7x4 back on it and it turned into a instant DOG!!!!!! I don't feel these engines can use a larger than normal prop as proposed from reading. It may work running them like that on a freeflight but not in control line. I found starting the Black Widow much easier with the 5x3 vs the 7x4 equally. I've experimented with 4 different engines now and conclusively had the same results with prop sizes. However, I found the Black Widow certainly does better in performance which is no surprise actually. Ken
Ken Cook- Top Poster
- Posts : 5637
Join date : 2012-03-27
Location : pennsylvania
Re: dieselized Black Widow
Ken
I have never run a diesel airplane motor but have this thought
I see your type question a lot on each of the sites. With very few exceptions the theme seems to be that the conversions are never as good as a purpose built diesel engine
I intend to add one or more diesel engines to my kit of stuff in the future.
I think I will bypass any of the conversions and just get tried and true engines from the get go to play with. Hoping to bypass much of the frustration I see you and others relate to a lot
Have fun, I know you will.... I expect some of our better informed members will answer you soon
I have never run a diesel airplane motor but have this thought
I see your type question a lot on each of the sites. With very few exceptions the theme seems to be that the conversions are never as good as a purpose built diesel engine
I intend to add one or more diesel engines to my kit of stuff in the future.
I think I will bypass any of the conversions and just get tried and true engines from the get go to play with. Hoping to bypass much of the frustration I see you and others relate to a lot
Have fun, I know you will.... I expect some of our better informed members will answer you soon
fredvon4- Top Poster
-
Posts : 4012
Join date : 2011-08-26
Age : 69
Location : Lampasas Texas
Re: dieselized Black Widow
I haven't worked with dieselizing any of the .049 engines from Cox, so I cannot really give much advice there, but I'm just wondering if you have tried engines with and without SPI?
The Cox engines that I have converted, a .020 PeeWee and the .07 Queen Bee, both behaved much like traditional diesels. I.e. they produce a high amount of power already at low revs with large props. With the large props it is also much easier to stay on the safe side, i.e. a little rich and undercompressed. It is on smaller props that I have been close to getting a runnaway situation. So in general I prop the engines to to about 10000-12000rpm maximum, if I prop them to run higher revs I have the risks of getting the runaway situation.
So, I would suggest getting you tach out and try a few props to see which prop will make it spin at around 10-12krpm. Going from a 7x4 to a 5x3 prop is a really big jump, why not try with a 6x4 and 6x3 as well?
As a comparison the PeeWee is very happy with a 6x3 prop, while the QueenBee will swing a 7x4 to 8x4 prop.
The Cox engines that I have converted, a .020 PeeWee and the .07 Queen Bee, both behaved much like traditional diesels. I.e. they produce a high amount of power already at low revs with large props. With the large props it is also much easier to stay on the safe side, i.e. a little rich and undercompressed. It is on smaller props that I have been close to getting a runnaway situation. So in general I prop the engines to to about 10000-12000rpm maximum, if I prop them to run higher revs I have the risks of getting the runaway situation.
So, I would suggest getting you tach out and try a few props to see which prop will make it spin at around 10-12krpm. Going from a 7x4 to a 5x3 prop is a really big jump, why not try with a 6x4 and 6x3 as well?
As a comparison the PeeWee is very happy with a 6x3 prop, while the QueenBee will swing a 7x4 to 8x4 prop.
Surfer_kris- Diamond Member
- Posts : 1912
Join date : 2010-11-20
Location : Sweden
Re: dieselized Black Widow
fredvon4 wrote:
I think I will bypass any of the conversions and just get tried and true engines from the get go to play with. Hoping to bypass much of the frustration I see you and others relate to a lot
Yes, for a novice to diesel engines I would certainly recommend to begin with dedicated diesel engines and commercial diesel fuel.
Once you have the experience though, it is part of the fun to see which engines that one can convert and which engines that are suitable for conversions. It is the timid glow engines that will make the best conversions, total power might be similar but the prop size will be much more useful and they will run very smooth on diesel with a soft exhaust note. Take the Queen Bee engine for example, it will only tolerate a 6x3 prop on glow, anything larger and it will overheat. Very frustrating and impractical. On diesel it will instead easily spin an 8x4 prop and provide much more trust, perfect for an old-school slow-flying plane.
Surfer_kris- Diamond Member
- Posts : 1912
Join date : 2010-11-20
Location : Sweden
Re: dieselized Black Widow
I found that the best way to get "diesel" performance out of a Bee was to reduce the venturi size - until I did that it gobbled fuel.
I am not a fan of the Davis Diesel heads but have done quite a lot with them and because of their construction - they don't dissipate heat very well. To compensate for this I jacked up the ether to 40% and reduced the paraffin content and the oil from the traditional British mix.
I ended up with 40% ether, 30% paraffin and 30% castor (about 1% ignition improver).
It worked well on this but when I knocked the castor down to 20% and upped the paraffin to 40% - the head went into melt down. I have not used a DD head since.
You are probably right about using these for control line - I have only experience of these being used with free flight RC assist but have seen them run happily on 8x4s.
I like the phrase "Runs like a dog" - I like the sound of diesels barking!
The best Cox "diesel" I have is still the Valentine TD build but that has a purpose made cylinder with contra piston. The venturi is reduced size as well.
Any diesel is a trial and error from running setting to flight. Keep it on the rich side with the compression set back slightly with little tweaks following flights but I think the problem you are seeing maybe the engine overheating with the DD head.
I am not a fan of the Davis Diesel heads but have done quite a lot with them and because of their construction - they don't dissipate heat very well. To compensate for this I jacked up the ether to 40% and reduced the paraffin content and the oil from the traditional British mix.
I ended up with 40% ether, 30% paraffin and 30% castor (about 1% ignition improver).
It worked well on this but when I knocked the castor down to 20% and upped the paraffin to 40% - the head went into melt down. I have not used a DD head since.
You are probably right about using these for control line - I have only experience of these being used with free flight RC assist but have seen them run happily on 8x4s.
I like the phrase "Runs like a dog" - I like the sound of diesels barking!
The best Cox "diesel" I have is still the Valentine TD build but that has a purpose made cylinder with contra piston. The venturi is reduced size as well.
Any diesel is a trial and error from running setting to flight. Keep it on the rich side with the compression set back slightly with little tweaks following flights but I think the problem you are seeing maybe the engine overheating with the DD head.
ian1954- Diamond Member
- Posts : 2688
Join date : 2011-11-16
Age : 70
Location : England
Re: dieselized Black Widow
Kris, I'm thinking the same as yourself. Here's why I didn't go for the 6x4. I don't have any because I gave them all away. They're useless for control line flying so I don't own any.I pretty much use 5" props for almost all of my use. However, I recognized very quickly that this is a prop that I readily need. I can pick some up from my fellow flyers but I haven't been to the field in months. The problem I found with trading a 5x3 to a 7x4 is that they require totally different starting procedures such as needling and compression. It's somewhat of a two handed starting procedure as your turning the contra piston and flipping at the same time. Once I get a pop I stop and start opening the needle. As for purpose built diesels. If I was to get serious in purpose built diesels I would probably go with the PAW. I like the looks and quality. They're a bit of money so as if I don't have enough stuff I figured I try these due to having them given to me. I have two different kinds of fuel which is the old Red Max and a old quart of Davis Diesel. The Red Max knocks you on your rear when you open it but it starts far easier. The Davis fuel hasn't been too reliable for me. It could also be old but it was in a sealed can. As for fuel, I can't comment on oil or ether content as they were both commercially made. The Red Max though fired everything up even in 20 deg temps so I'm somewhat favoring this brew.
I think with all my experimentation, I will conclude even based on your experiences as well Kris that this engine will be much happier in the middle with a 6" prop. My flying experience has been pretty poor with them using a 7" prop. As Ian mentions though the Davis head does tend to overheat or over compress. I don't know what ot make of it other than the engine begins to sag. I never found any .049 to ever overheat as I feel you can never get enough heat in them. So I will say over compress. This is pretty cool stuff and I see Bob aka Fit90 has had similar fun in doing so lately.
I think with all my experimentation, I will conclude even based on your experiences as well Kris that this engine will be much happier in the middle with a 6" prop. My flying experience has been pretty poor with them using a 7" prop. As Ian mentions though the Davis head does tend to overheat or over compress. I don't know what ot make of it other than the engine begins to sag. I never found any .049 to ever overheat as I feel you can never get enough heat in them. So I will say over compress. This is pretty cool stuff and I see Bob aka Fit90 has had similar fun in doing so lately.
Ken Cook- Top Poster
- Posts : 5637
Join date : 2012-03-27
Location : pennsylvania
Re: dieselized Black Widow
Why not just fit a glow head to the Coxs and make sure they run as expected that way first? Once you're satisfied that the engine is running as it should as a glow and you're sure it's run in correctly switch back to the diesel head. That should eliminate everything else apart from the head, fuel & compression setting.
I really don't see why the 7X4 should cause too much of a problem as a Texaco runs fine on 7", although they do have more cooling fins on the head so the larger prop must heat them up.
I really don't see why the 7X4 should cause too much of a problem as a Texaco runs fine on 7", although they do have more cooling fins on the head so the larger prop must heat them up.
Oldenginerod- Top Poster
- Posts : 4018
Join date : 2012-06-15
Age : 62
Location : Drouin, Victoria
Re: dieselized Black Widow
Ken,
Glad to see you joining the diesel fun. I have only had mixed luck with Cox bee type engines using the RJL head. I also used the head on a Valentine speed bee with a die cast case. The performance was quite good at a little over 10,000 rpm with an MAS 7x4, but the head got too hot to adjust by hand. The three best Cox conversions, for me, have been the queen bee, a straight medallion and putting an aluminum carb body and cox carb on a medallion. All these started easily and performed well. If memory serves me correctly, I think they were giving slightly over 10,000 rpm on an 8x4, just not completely certain of that.
Bob
Glad to see you joining the diesel fun. I have only had mixed luck with Cox bee type engines using the RJL head. I also used the head on a Valentine speed bee with a die cast case. The performance was quite good at a little over 10,000 rpm with an MAS 7x4, but the head got too hot to adjust by hand. The three best Cox conversions, for me, have been the queen bee, a straight medallion and putting an aluminum carb body and cox carb on a medallion. All these started easily and performed well. If memory serves me correctly, I think they were giving slightly over 10,000 rpm on an 8x4, just not completely certain of that.
Bob
fit90- Diamond Member
- Posts : 1341
Join date : 2011-08-11
Location : Naples, Florida
Similar topics
» Black Widow?
» How about a NIB Cox Black Widow for $6.27?
» Black Widow "touch up"?
» Black Widow on E bay
» Best way to lower the ports on an .049 cylinder.
» How about a NIB Cox Black Widow for $6.27?
» Black Widow "touch up"?
» Black Widow on E bay
» Best way to lower the ports on an .049 cylinder.
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum