Log in
Search
Latest topics
» Roger Harris revisitedby TD ABUSER Today at 2:30 am
» My latest doodle...
by batjac Yesterday at 10:05 pm
» Retail price mark-up.. how much is enough?
by gkamysz Yesterday at 9:29 pm
» Happy 77th birthday Andrew!
by roddie Yesterday at 9:22 pm
» My N-1R build log
by GallopingGhostler Yesterday at 3:04 pm
» Tee Dee .020 combat model
by 1/2A Nut Yesterday at 2:43 pm
» Chocolate chip cookie dough.........
by roddie Yesterday at 1:13 pm
» Purchased the last of any bult engines from Ken Enya
by sosam117 Yesterday at 11:32 am
» Free Flight Radio Assist
by rdw777 Yesterday at 9:24 am
» Funny what you find when you go looking
by rsv1cox Wed Nov 20, 2024 3:21 pm
» Landing-gear tips
by 1975 control line guy Wed Nov 20, 2024 8:17 am
» Cox NaBOO - Just in time for Halloween
by rsv1cox Tue Nov 19, 2024 6:35 pm
Cox Engine of The Month
Symptoms of fuel going bad
Page 1 of 1
Symptoms of fuel going bad
I know my fuel is old but what are the symptoms of bad fuel? I am experiencing test runs that sounds rich, but are not. Any further leaning and the engine sags. I noticed this last week with a different set up on the engine.
chevyiron420- Gold Member
- Posts : 251
Join date : 2015-01-28
Age : 66
Location : Barney Georgia
Re: Symptoms of fuel going bad
Nirto methane , methanol, and bean oil or synthetic oils all deteriorate in different ways
Nitro Methane is mostly changed by UV Light and must be in a opaque container best is metal
Methanol the alcohol is hydroscopic (it absorbs water from the air) and must be in any air tight container
Castor oils can last for decades with no degradation but do occasionally need to be agitated to re homogenize in the fuel mix
There are too many synthetic oils to address individually but beware some are intended to mix in Gasoline and others are designed for Alcohol based fuels
I personally buy cheap high nitro car fuel that has too low oil content and use my stash of nitro, methanol, and oils to mix for Cox engine performance
I went on line years ago and bought a stash of pint, quart, half gallon and Gallon metal cans and good tops from the Carry company (google)
Since 1972 to present, My experience is properly stored fuels are pretty much good for a very long time
Just as an aside...water condensation in a car, lawn mower or weed eater is easy top asses and see, and adding a little ethanol or methanol with absorb the water and let it be consumed.
Unfortunately when our Methanol based fuels absorb water from the atmosphere, it is actually absorbed by the alcohol and slightly changes the rations of Nitro, Methanol, oils.
Quite frankly this small amount of water in the fuel is only a concern to top level competition fliers who demand a consistent engine run.
We sport and occasional engine guys rarely can even detect the inconsistencies unless we are logging , sound, rpm and stable idles as we screw around with our toys.
Bottom line IMO, if you suspect you have a bad batch of fuel ...buy or make better fuel and use the crap for engine cleaning or break in runs
Nitro Methane is mostly changed by UV Light and must be in a opaque container best is metal
Methanol the alcohol is hydroscopic (it absorbs water from the air) and must be in any air tight container
Castor oils can last for decades with no degradation but do occasionally need to be agitated to re homogenize in the fuel mix
There are too many synthetic oils to address individually but beware some are intended to mix in Gasoline and others are designed for Alcohol based fuels
I personally buy cheap high nitro car fuel that has too low oil content and use my stash of nitro, methanol, and oils to mix for Cox engine performance
I went on line years ago and bought a stash of pint, quart, half gallon and Gallon metal cans and good tops from the Carry company (google)
Since 1972 to present, My experience is properly stored fuels are pretty much good for a very long time
Just as an aside...water condensation in a car, lawn mower or weed eater is easy top asses and see, and adding a little ethanol or methanol with absorb the water and let it be consumed.
Unfortunately when our Methanol based fuels absorb water from the atmosphere, it is actually absorbed by the alcohol and slightly changes the rations of Nitro, Methanol, oils.
Quite frankly this small amount of water in the fuel is only a concern to top level competition fliers who demand a consistent engine run.
We sport and occasional engine guys rarely can even detect the inconsistencies unless we are logging , sound, rpm and stable idles as we screw around with our toys.
Bottom line IMO, if you suspect you have a bad batch of fuel ...buy or make better fuel and use the crap for engine cleaning or break in runs
Last edited by fredvon4 on Mon Jan 23, 2023 5:51 am; edited 1 time in total
fredvon4- Top Poster
-
Posts : 4012
Join date : 2011-08-26
Age : 69
Location : Lampasas Texas
Re: Symptoms of fuel going bad
I have some old 40% that did not want to start well, and blew a plug when running off a prime. Some 10% was a few years old and it ran well the one year and the next year the motor just would not start. They were both tightly capped in a dry basement. A model boat that I got at a swap meet had a tank of synth fuel in it. It sat for probably 5 years without running. The level just kept going down and there was just syrup left. Klotz. So I guess in that case the methanol and nitro just evaporated from the vent pressure line. So I can imagine it would not ignite well and run poorly until it is just pure oil. Then again there could be it picking up moisture. I did not use a lot of fuel years ago when running 1/2A and .15s. A gallon could last 3 years. Only the last 10 years that I use a bit more fuel because it is too windy here for the smaller slow planes.
aspeed- Platinum Member
- Posts : 796
Join date : 2013-01-18
Location : Leamington Ont. Can.
Re: Symptoms of fuel going bad
I used to use a lot of methanol each week for about 3/4 of the year in dirt speedway. Only once had any problem with the methanol although it tended to get used very quickly and was often bought from a place that specialised in supplying racing fuel and the methanol was stored in big tanks underground and we had drums filled at the station. Other times I used drums of methanol that were pre-filled and distributed as such. Again, they never were kept by me for long. I did store them on a wooden shelf approx 2 feet off the ground and away from the wall. The only time I had a bad fuel incident was a night at the speedway where a number of us that bought fuel that night from the same distributors pumps had problems that seemed more than co-incidental. The fuel looked ok, colour was good etc. but a number of us had problems with engines not reving to peak properly.
The easiest way I now to identify a fuel based problem is to get some fuel from another source, run it in an engine, maybe a different engine, prove the fuel to be good, then run it in the engine having problems. The reverse can also be done by running an engine with known good fuel and then with the suspect fuel and see if the problem follows the fuel. The engine having problems may need the tank and engine and lines flushed to remove the problem dependent on what it is. Some additives eat neoprene type engine seals and it can cause various problems.
In 15 years of racing very high performance two stroke and four stroke engines, I can only say fuel ( Methanol ) was the cause once for me of engine problems ( I did also mix fuels and use additives such as toluene in AV gas not in Methanol ) and I dont really know why that fuel caused the problems that night. The distributor wouldnt say, and the fuel from same pumps was all ok a week later ( though in that time it could have been fixed. many rumours were afloat, but nothing more than rumours)
Maybe I was just lucky. I stored fuel as well as I thought was possible. Didnt let it age overly. Kept away from sunlight, used storage drums / containers as recommended by disrtibutor. Kept drums filled to the top, dated drums and used them such that none got old, or if they did, I knew how old. Both AV Gas and Methanol, plus storing Toluene. I disposed of fuel leftover in car or bike fuel tanks, flushed the fuel systems and engine after every race meeting, didnt keep small leftovers in drums. The same practices scale down to model engines as well.
Your luck / experiences may vary
Yabby
The easiest way I now to identify a fuel based problem is to get some fuel from another source, run it in an engine, maybe a different engine, prove the fuel to be good, then run it in the engine having problems. The reverse can also be done by running an engine with known good fuel and then with the suspect fuel and see if the problem follows the fuel. The engine having problems may need the tank and engine and lines flushed to remove the problem dependent on what it is. Some additives eat neoprene type engine seals and it can cause various problems.
In 15 years of racing very high performance two stroke and four stroke engines, I can only say fuel ( Methanol ) was the cause once for me of engine problems ( I did also mix fuels and use additives such as toluene in AV gas not in Methanol ) and I dont really know why that fuel caused the problems that night. The distributor wouldnt say, and the fuel from same pumps was all ok a week later ( though in that time it could have been fixed. many rumours were afloat, but nothing more than rumours)
Maybe I was just lucky. I stored fuel as well as I thought was possible. Didnt let it age overly. Kept away from sunlight, used storage drums / containers as recommended by disrtibutor. Kept drums filled to the top, dated drums and used them such that none got old, or if they did, I knew how old. Both AV Gas and Methanol, plus storing Toluene. I disposed of fuel leftover in car or bike fuel tanks, flushed the fuel systems and engine after every race meeting, didnt keep small leftovers in drums. The same practices scale down to model engines as well.
Your luck / experiences may vary
Yabby
Yabby- Platinum Member
-
Posts : 712
Join date : 2021-06-08
Location : Yorke Peninsula South Australia
Re: Symptoms of fuel going bad
fredvon4 wrote:......
I personally buy cheap high nitro car fuel that has too low oil content and use my stash of nitro, methanol, and oils to mix for Cox engine performance
........
I've taken this approach since most airplane fuel is becoming increasingly more difficult to find, unless online. However, nitro anywhere close to my location is now unobtainium and methanol is becoming that way. I do use Klotz BeNol and Klotz Original Techniplate for oil sources.
Can anyone verify that Heet (yellow bottle) Gas Line Treatment is methanol and that it can be used as a fuel source?
a--
Re: Symptoms of fuel going bad
Hi All,
At -15C,
Castor oil congeles on inside of plastic jugs.
Mix well,
Have fun,
Good glow,
Dave
At -15C,
Castor oil congeles on inside of plastic jugs.
Mix well,
Have fun,
Good glow,
Dave
HalfaDave- Platinum Member
- Posts : 615
Join date : 2022-12-06
Location : Oakville, Ontario
Re: Symptoms of fuel going bad
Of course I failed to adequately answer the original question
IMO all Cox small engines were designed to run BEST on 25 to 35% Nitro. Yes there are users who profess to successfully start and run on 0% nitro and even some who claim 100% synthetic oil is just fine
I have been patiently waiting Ken Cook to chime in as he (IMO) is our CEF GURU on this subject
That said, good fuel vs bad fuel is too subjective to really determine. You got good advise on how to determine via experimentation.
Scientific evaluation is not hard to set up and test:
Requires: Known good engine on Known fresh good fuel
The variables: Funky engine, Good engine, low Nitro fuel, high nitro fuel, old fuel, new fuel and sooner than later you have to accept that the permutations are too vast to seriously come to any perfect conclusion
Thus In the final analysis it is necessary to come to some compendium of past knowledge, and you did just that with asking on CEF
So a Lot of words to tell you. DEFINITIVLEY: Use your questionable fuel for test and cleaning only, do only FLY known good fuel as it will provide CONSISTANT engine runs
Advice: If interested in playing with Cox or other small internal combustion engines for the next many years---The buy bulk Nitro, Methanol, and appropriate Lubes to eventually mix or blend your own ....lots of folk right now can not conceive that a Gallon of ANY fuel is approaching or well over $40 per gallon
Contrast...I still have too many 2 stroke yard and lawn implements that require fuel ,,,pump gasoline has too much corn crap, store bought Gasoline with out any corn is $9+ per quart or $36 per gallon....So I have experimented with running my chain saws, weed eaters and leaf blowers on Nitro /Methanol based fuels.. with some success....Jest saying
IMO all Cox small engines were designed to run BEST on 25 to 35% Nitro. Yes there are users who profess to successfully start and run on 0% nitro and even some who claim 100% synthetic oil is just fine
I have been patiently waiting Ken Cook to chime in as he (IMO) is our CEF GURU on this subject
That said, good fuel vs bad fuel is too subjective to really determine. You got good advise on how to determine via experimentation.
Scientific evaluation is not hard to set up and test:
Requires: Known good engine on Known fresh good fuel
The variables: Funky engine, Good engine, low Nitro fuel, high nitro fuel, old fuel, new fuel and sooner than later you have to accept that the permutations are too vast to seriously come to any perfect conclusion
Thus In the final analysis it is necessary to come to some compendium of past knowledge, and you did just that with asking on CEF
So a Lot of words to tell you. DEFINITIVLEY: Use your questionable fuel for test and cleaning only, do only FLY known good fuel as it will provide CONSISTANT engine runs
Advice: If interested in playing with Cox or other small internal combustion engines for the next many years---The buy bulk Nitro, Methanol, and appropriate Lubes to eventually mix or blend your own ....lots of folk right now can not conceive that a Gallon of ANY fuel is approaching or well over $40 per gallon
Contrast...I still have too many 2 stroke yard and lawn implements that require fuel ,,,pump gasoline has too much corn crap, store bought Gasoline with out any corn is $9+ per quart or $36 per gallon....So I have experimented with running my chain saws, weed eaters and leaf blowers on Nitro /Methanol based fuels.. with some success....Jest saying
fredvon4- Top Poster
-
Posts : 4012
Join date : 2011-08-26
Age : 69
Location : Lampasas Texas
Re: Symptoms of fuel going bad
Side note as I openly advocate making your own fuel
Point 1, most RC shops with Alcohol fuels pander to RC cars and not aircraft. I have found 35% nitro but only 17% oil gallons for $12~$19 many places
Torco on E-bay sell pure nitro for around $50 shipped
Methanol is usually available locally for between $2 and $15 per gallon ----look for local race tracks , cart, motocross, drag
A lot of companies sell Alcohol soluble oils: Castor is necessary IMO but there are many blends of synthetic and castor.
I have 2 gallons of Nitro. 2 gallons of Methanol, and about 1.5 gallons of various Castor and blended oils as well as a few pints of oil additives from Randy Smith
Using a 35% nitro /17% RC car racing fuel at $12 per gallon I can blend any variable I need for my small engines
HINT
I am an American tied to pints, quarts, and gallons...BUT I find Base ten mathematics too easy to not use...I do use the metric system for all my blending
Screw how many ozs are in a pint, quart, gallon...
1 Liter (like a quart) is 1000 milliliter.
Too simple: to make about a quart of fuel with 35% nitro, 22% oil 43 % Methanol the math is easy
35% of 1000 is 350 ML
22% of 100 is 220 ML
the reminder is 43% or 435 Methanol or 430 ML
Amazon is your friend for ML graduated beakers ....final hint
Point 1, most RC shops with Alcohol fuels pander to RC cars and not aircraft. I have found 35% nitro but only 17% oil gallons for $12~$19 many places
Torco on E-bay sell pure nitro for around $50 shipped
Methanol is usually available locally for between $2 and $15 per gallon ----look for local race tracks , cart, motocross, drag
A lot of companies sell Alcohol soluble oils: Castor is necessary IMO but there are many blends of synthetic and castor.
I have 2 gallons of Nitro. 2 gallons of Methanol, and about 1.5 gallons of various Castor and blended oils as well as a few pints of oil additives from Randy Smith
Using a 35% nitro /17% RC car racing fuel at $12 per gallon I can blend any variable I need for my small engines
HINT
I am an American tied to pints, quarts, and gallons...BUT I find Base ten mathematics too easy to not use...I do use the metric system for all my blending
Screw how many ozs are in a pint, quart, gallon...
1 Liter (like a quart) is 1000 milliliter.
Too simple: to make about a quart of fuel with 35% nitro, 22% oil 43 % Methanol the math is easy
35% of 1000 is 350 ML
22% of 100 is 220 ML
the reminder is 43% or 435 Methanol or 430 ML
Amazon is your friend for ML graduated beakers ....final hint
fredvon4- Top Poster
-
Posts : 4012
Join date : 2011-08-26
Age : 69
Location : Lampasas Texas
Similar topics
» Bad reed symptoms?
» What are the symptoms of a leaking venturi o-ring?
» New Uploads: 1982 and 1990 Cox Catalogs, and Hobbico-Cox Super Power Fuel Flyer
» Black Widow RPM
» [solved]Is cox still in business? I cant find anything on their site!
» What are the symptoms of a leaking venturi o-ring?
» New Uploads: 1982 and 1990 Cox Catalogs, and Hobbico-Cox Super Power Fuel Flyer
» Black Widow RPM
» [solved]Is cox still in business? I cant find anything on their site!
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum